{
  "version": "p19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract.v1",
  "created_at": "2026-06-02T03:46:19.065975Z",
  "phase": "P19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract",
  "project_root": "/wwwb/aitools/writer",
  "output_run_dir": "outputs/p19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract_20260602_034618",
  "source_artifacts": {
    "p19_contract": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/p19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract_20260602.md",
      "sha256": "18411719f5ec91f9adaaa0b856055058c5f206d95a4f9f7193e97cee5d67f247",
      "size_bytes": 13042,
      "exists": true
    },
    "p18_closeout_retrospective": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/p18_closeout_retrospective_20260602.md",
      "sha256": "b78bc876fef30992f7cbe1a1f545eef5c0df2e81ce5978456b5e3f02afad4c94",
      "size_bytes": 8332,
      "exists": true
    },
    "p18_contract": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract_20260602.md",
      "sha256": "eb15879d5bcfc71ab2c33b9c34bae6a42f12f981b6f005ff6ac17da403a4cb67",
      "size_bytes": 8571,
      "exists": true
    },
    "p18_gate": {
      "artifact": "P18_handoff_alignment_gate.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_gate.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 8859,
      "sha256": "a6b81c9dc0b2c28511dabb8e3fa431c9723d7036cad54aeb4a09e3e39348e4a3"
    },
    "p18_validator": {
      "artifact": "P18_handoff_alignment_validator_report.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_validator_report.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 5187,
      "sha256": "b21dfc65f43539fbd4688427f93ea27b30460db035917a2372f43f2bcd79cfcc"
    },
    "p18_input": {
      "artifact": "P18_handoff_alignment_input.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_input.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 43490,
      "sha256": "5b2de12ee6757a18e3a36c32e0ecf6a784307aa33eabecaeaf52df808c0f225c"
    },
    "p18_schema_alignment": {
      "artifact": "P18_manual_log_schema_alignment.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_manual_log_schema_alignment.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 744140,
      "sha256": "e6badc65b4fbcf783c34c05952881b6dbd71cf7e647c345b1727d31b89b58e51"
    },
    "p18_route_lookup": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_pending_evidence_route_lookup.jsonl",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "9759b8268da7bf91a991a6693f53a3aa4b165e870b71cdf091dc07392e04877f",
      "size_bytes": 2250900
    },
    "p18_queue": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_dependency_queue.jsonl",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "db507b9dc256c454960d51ef8725361e43932f8e69c28d4b6a91c469ab163d26",
      "size_bytes": 2042
    },
    "p18_manifest": {
      "artifact": "manifest.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/manifest.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 6359,
      "sha256": "d0af24db490517cd038ad5f903607e3135403ae9ce87279863c3689baeb45c2d"
    },
    "p18_program_validation": {
      "artifact": "P18_handoff_alignment_program_validation.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_20260602_112954/P18_handoff_alignment_program_validation.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 6098,
      "sha256": "f0fe688d9afaa4bfbe1aafa98a5deeaebb5478901247653ca3498a21db9b5e6d"
    },
    "p18_deepseek_gate": {
      "artifact": "P18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_gate.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_20260602_112954/P18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_gate.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 3883,
      "sha256": "0acd0fc3d946422a0d311aa42a49647e834d8c8039cdb830d93ecfd8326e3e83"
    },
    "p18_deepseek_raw": {
      "artifact": "P18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_raw.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_20260602_112954/P18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_raw.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 103120,
      "sha256": "00ea4282f3709c7237259d0fc59a7cd354e0aba1d26727f9657a1de5d0a62fd1"
    },
    "execution_state": {
      "artifact": "execution_state.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/execution_state.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 69661,
      "sha256": "fe4a88c35d4234270bebbfa069b64835b58bb464ea33b3020c2aa2c512cf9111"
    },
    "phase_acceptance": {
      "artifact": "phase_acceptance.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/phase_acceptance.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 81566,
      "sha256": "76121d0f5f6f3852fa43e9e7db3415f41ffeac253cdf0fbe7eaae7fc118f50c3"
    }
  },
  "contract_checks": {
    "p19_contract_present": true,
    "p19_contract_future_schema_scope": true,
    "p19_contract_p18_explicit_authority": true,
    "p19_contract_required_outputs": true,
    "p19_contract_validator_matrix_bound": true,
    "p19_contract_feedback_intake_blocked": true,
    "p19_contract_no_writeback": true,
    "p19_contract_old_b7_reference_only": true
  },
  "p19_contract_excerpt": "# P19 Feedback Repair Replay Boundary Contract\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-02T11:33:00+08:00`\n\n本文冻结 P计划 `P19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract` 的规划细则。P19 是 P18 handoff alignment closeout 后的下一候选阶段。P19 只定义未来真实 provider/operator feedback、repair、replay 的边界、schema、validator 和 no-writeback policy；它不 ingest 真实反馈，不生成 provider/operator evidence，不执行 repair/replay，不写 KG/overlay/replay，也不改写 `outputs/index.json` / `outputs/index-lite.json`。\n\n## Contract ID\n\n`P19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract`\n\n## Objective\n\nP19 的目标是在 P18 pending handoff alignment 后建立 feedback/repair/replay 的安全边界：\n\n- consume P18 handoff alignment run, P18 program validation/advisory gate, and P18 closeout retrospective by explicit path。\n- preserve Now-32 as the active provider/manual execution evidence gate without changing `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`。\n- define future provider result evidence slot contract without filling provider result fields。\n- define future operator observation schema without creating operator decisions。\n- define future issue classification schema for provider/manual feedback defects。\n- define future repair task schema that can be populated only from real evidence under a later authorized stage。\n- define replay eligibility rules that remain blocked until real evidence, repair output, operator acceptance, and validator checks exist。\n- define no-canonical-writeback, no-overlay-writeback, no-replay-execution, no-index-mutation guards。\n- keep old B7 as paused downstream reference only。\n- require P19 program validation, DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory, closeout retrospective, and control-plane sync before P20 final index/archive/workspace hygiene advances。\n\nP19 may produce contract artifacts, validator matrices, empty schemas, report/html, and a dependency queue. It must not produce filled feedback, filled provider results, filled operator observations, repair outputs, replay actions, accepted overlay rows, operator overlay rows, canonical KG rows, raw KG rows, or generated index rewrites.\n\n## Required Inputs\n\n- `docs/p19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract_20260602.md`\n- `docs/p18_closeout_retrospective_20260602.md`\n- `docs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract_20260602.md`\n- `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_gate.json`\n- `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_validator_report.json`\n- `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_input.json`\n- `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_manual_log_schema_alignment.json`\n- `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_pending_evidence_route_lookup.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/manifest.json`\n- `outputs/p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_20260602_112954/P18_handoff_alignment_program_validation.json`\n- `outputs/p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_20260602_112954/P18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_gate.json`\n- `outputs/p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_20260602_112954/P18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_raw.json`\n- `phase_acceptance.json`\n- `execution_state.json`\n\nP19 must not discover P18 through generated indexes. Use explicit paths unless a later deterministic index-refresh stage is opened.\n\n## Execution Boundary\n\nP19 may execute boundary planning artifacts only:\n\n- allowed: read P18 artifacts by explicit path, define JSON schema stubs, define validator rows, define no-writeback policy, generate gate/report/html/manifest, and log a dependency queue。\n- not allowed: provider job execution, media generation, filled provider result evidence, filled manual/operator evidence, feedback intake, repair output generation, replay eligibility approval, replay execution, KG writeback, raw KG writeback, accepted/operator overlay writeback, output deletion, output cold archive, generated index mutation。\n- DeepSeek advisory is required after P19 conclusive artifacts, but remains advisory-only and cannot become accepted operator evidence, accepted overlay, KG fact, replay action, provider evidence, manual evidence, or runtime routing logic。\n- Runtime branching by entity name, work title, block title, or sample text is prohibited. Entity names, work titles, block titles, and source excerpts may appear only as evidence/display text.\n\n## Future Provider Result Evidence Slot Contract\n\nP19 should define empty schema slots for later real provider result evidence:\n\n- `provider_job_id`: optional until real provider execution exists.\n- `provider_name`: enum or controlled string supplied by the evidence stage.\n- `provider_model_or_product`: controlled string supplied by the evidence stage.\n- `adapter_render_id`: required ref to P17/P18 lineage.\n- `manual_handoff_template_id`: required ref to P18 template when execution came from P18 handoff.\n- `submitted_prompt_payload_ref`: required only when a real submitted payload artifact exists.\n- `submitted_at`: required only for real provider submission.\n- `completed_at`: optional real provider timestamp.\n- `provider_status`: one of `pending`, `submitted`, `completed`, `failed`, `cancelled`, `unknown`.\n- `provider_response_artifact_ref`: optional path/ref to real provider response metadata.\n- `media_artifact_ref`: optional path/ref to real media; never fabricated.\n- `provider_error_code`: optional real provider error.\n- `provider_error_message`: optional real provider error text.\n- `evidence_collected_by`: required only when real evidence is supplied.\n- `evidence_collected_at`: required only when real evidence is supplied.\n\nAll fields that imply real execution must remain absent, null, or explicitly `pending_evidence` in P19 artifacts.\n\n## Future Operator Observation Schema\n\nP19 should define empty schema slots for later operator observations:\n\n- `operator_observation_id`\n- `provider_result_evidence_id`\n- `operator_id`\n- `observed_at`\n- `observation_scope`: `prompt`, `adapter`, `provider_result`, `media`, `continuity`, `style`, `safety`, `other`\n- `observation_status`: `pending`, `accepted`, `needs_repair`, `rejected`, `deferred`\n- `issue_refs`\n- `freeform_note`\n- `source_evidence_refs`\n- `accepted_by`\n- `accepted_at`\n\nP19 must not fill `operator_id`, `accepted_by`, `accepted_at`, or any accepted decision field unless real operator evidence is later supplied under an authorized evidence stage.\n\n## Future Issue Classification Schema\n\nP19 should define future issue classes without creating issues:\n\n- `provider_rejection`\n- `provider_parameter_unsupported`\n- `provider_prompt_syntax_error`\n- `media_missing`\n- `media_quality_defect`\n- `visual_identity_drift`\n- `continuity_break`\n- `shot_context_mismatch`\n- `prompt_packet_trace_gap`\n- `adapter_payload_trace_gap`\n- `manual_execution_log_gap`\n- `operator_observation_conflict`\n- `evidence_integrity_gap`\n\nEach future issue must carry source refs, observed evidence refs, severity, repairability, replay impact, and blocking status. P19 only defines this matrix.\n\n## Future Repair Task Schema\n\nP19 should define future repair task fields:\n\n- `repair_task_id`\n- `source_issue_id`\n- `repair_scope`: `prompt_packet`, `adapter_render`, `manual_handoff`, `shot_context`, `shooting_script`, `screenplay`, `style`, `provider_profile`, `other`\n- `repair_action`: controlled enum defined by P19 validator matrix.\n- `input_refs`\n- `proposed_output_refs`\n- `requires_operator_acceptance`\n- `requires_provider_rerun`\n- `canonical_writeback_allowed`: always `false` unless a future separate evidence/acceptance contract opens it.\n- `overlay_writeback_allowed`: always `false` unless a future separate evidence/acceptance contract opens it.\n- `replay_allowed`: always `false` in P19.\n\nP19 must not generate actual repaired prompt rows, adapter renders, KG rows, overlay rows, or replay queue entries.\n\n## Future Replay Eligibility Rules\n\nReplay eligibility remains blocked unless a later stage has all of the following:\n\n- real provider result evidence or real operator observation evidence;\n- traceable issue classification from real evidence;\n- repair task with deterministic lineage and validator pass;\n- explicit operator acceptance where required;\n- no unresolved evidence-integrity gap;\n- no canonical/raw KG writeback unless separately authorized;\n- no accepted/operator overlay writeback unless separately authorized;\n- no replay execution without a fresh replay execution contract.\n\nP19 may output `replay_eligibility_default_status=blocked_pending_real_evidence_and_separate_replay_contract`.\n\n## Required Outputs\n\nP19 should write a fresh output run dir such as:\n\n`outputs/p19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract_<timestamp>`\n\nRequired files:\n\n- `P19_feedback_boundary_input.json`\n- `P19_provider_result_evidence_schema.json`\n- `P19_operator_observation_schema.json`\n- `P19_issue_classification_schema.json`\n- `P19_repair_task_schema.json`\n- `P19_replay_eligibility_rules.json`\n- `P19_feedback_repair_replay_validator_report.json`\n- `P19_feedback_repair_replay_gate.json`\n- `P19_feedback_repair_replay_report.md`\n- `P19_feedback_repair_replay.html`\n- `P19_feedback_repair_replay_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- `manifest.json`\n\n## P19 Validator Matrix\n\n| Validator | Required check | Blocks pass when |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| `p18_authority` | P19 consumes explicit P18 run/advisory/retrospective paths and verifies pass gates | P18 gate/advisory missing, not pass, or P18 retrospective missing |\n| `now32_active_route_guard` | `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.id` remains `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract` | active route changes |\n| `pending_evidence_guard` | Provider/operator evidence schemas are empty or pending only | any provider/operator evidence is filled or fabricated |\n| `feedback_intake_guard` | No real feedback is ingested in P19 | feedback rows or observed issues claim real evidence |\n| `repair_execution_guard` | No repaired prompt/adapter/KG/overlay output is generated | repair output appears as executed |\n| `replay_guard` | Replay eligibility remains blocked and no replay action exists | replay action or replay-eligible status appears |\n| `no_writeback_guard` | canonical/raw KG and accepted/operator overlay writes are zero | any writeback appears |\n| `provider_media_guard` | provider job/media counters remain zero | provider job or media generation appears |\n| `outputs_index_guard` | generated outputs indexes remain untouched | `outputs/index.json` or `outputs/index-lite.json` mutation is detected |\n| `old_b7_exclusion` | old B7 remains paused reference only | old B7 output is used as active authority |\n\n## DeepSeek Advisory Requirements\n\nP19 closeout requires DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory over:\n\n- P19 contract。\n- P18 closeout retrospective。\n- P19 boundary artifacts。\n- P19 validator report and gate。\n- Now-32 active route boundary from `execution_state.json` and `phase_acceptance.json`。\n\nExpected pass verdict:\n\n`supports_p19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract`\n\nPass requires:\n\n- DeepSeek call status=`success`。\n- parse status=`pass`。\n- finding/blocker/high=0/0/0。\n- advisory confirms P19 uses P18 fresh artifacts as active authority。\n- advisory confirms P19 defines future schemas only and does not fill provider/operator evidence。\n- advisory confirms feedback intake, repair execution, replay, provider/media, KG/overlay, and generated index mutation remain blocked。\n- advisory confirms old B7 remains reference-only。\n- advisory confirms Now-32 remains active route authority。\n\nMissing/skipped/unavailable/unparseable advisory blocks P19 closeout or records `blocked_unavailable`; it never counts as pass.\n\n## Non-Goals\n\n- P19 does not execute provider jobs。\n- P19 does not generate me",
  "p18_closeout_retrospective_excerpt": "# P18 Closeout Retrospective\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-02T11:33:00+08:00`\n\n本文是 P计划 `P18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract` 的阶段复盘。P18 在 P17 adapter render closeout 后执行 prompt-readiness / adapter-QA / manual handoff alignment。P18 只生成 pending-evidence handoff alignment artifacts，没有执行 provider job、media generation、manual/provider evidence、feedback/replay、KG/overlay/replay，也没有改写 `outputs/index.json` / `outputs/index-lite.json`。\n\n## Stage Result\n\n- Status: `pass`\n- P18 handoff alignment run: `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942`\n- P18 handoff alignment gate: `outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_20260602_112942/P18_handoff_alignment_gate.json`\n- P18 DeepSeek advisory run: `outputs/p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_20260602_112954`\n- P18 DeepSeek gate: `outputs/p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_20260602_112954/P18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit_gate.json`\n- Program validation: `pass`\n- DeepSeek verdict: `supports_p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract`\n- finding / blocker / high: `0 / 0 / 0`\n- false required confirmations: `0`\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`: unchanged, still `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\n\n## Actual Landed\n\nP18 landed a fresh handoff alignment stage:\n\n- `src/novel2video/p18_handoff_alignment.py`\n- `scripts/run_p18_handoff_alignment.py`\n- `scripts/run_p18_handoff_alignment_deepseek_audit.py`\n- `tests/test_p18_handoff_alignment.py`\n\nP18 output artifacts:\n\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_input.json`\n- `P18_adapter_readiness_qa_rows.jsonl`\n- `P18_manual_handoff_packet_templates.jsonl`\n- `P18_manual_log_schema_alignment.json`\n- `P18_pending_evidence_route_lookup.jsonl`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_validator_report.json`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_gate.json`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_report.md`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment.html`\n- `manifest.json`\n\nThe handoff templates align P17 adapter render refs with Now-32 manual log governance. They remain templates with pending evidence fields only. They are not provider output, operator decision, manual execution evidence, provider execution evidence, feedback intake, or replay eligibility evidence.\n\n## Metrics\n\n- P17 adapter render rows: `5002`\n- P18 adapter readiness QA rows: `5002`\n- P18 manual handoff templates: `5002`\n- pending evidence templates: `5002`\n- route lookup rows: `5002`\n- adapter render refs / prompt packet refs / P16 boundary refs: `5002 / 5002 / 5002`\n- shot ids / shot numbers traced: `5002 / 5002`\n- unsupported field refs propagated: `10004`\n- downgrade note refs propagated: `5002`\n- provider-specific syntax in handoff fields: `5002`\n- provider-specific syntax in provider-neutral or canonical layers: `0`\n- dependency queue items: `3`\n- future executable after P18 closeout: `1`\n- validator failures: `0`\n\nNo-side-effect counters:\n\n- provider job execution: `0`\n- media generation: `0`\n- manual provider evidence: `0`\n- feedback intake: `0`\n- accepted/operator overlay write: `0 / 0`\n- canonical/raw KG writeback: `0 / 0`\n- replay action: `0`\n- outputs index mutation: `0`\n- fake provider result: `0`\n- fake operator decision: `0`\n- old B7 active source refs: `0`\n\n## Program Validation\n\nFocused validation passed:\n\n- P18 gate pass.\n- P18 validator pass.\n- Required P18 files exist and are listed in manifest.\n- QA rows, handoff templates, and route lookup rows are complete: `5002 / 5002 / 5002`.\n- Manual handoff templates use pending evidence only.\n- Unsupported field refs and downgrade note refs are propagated.\n- Provider syntax stays inside adapter/handoff fields.\n- Provider-neutral/canonical layers have zero provider-specific syntax.\n- Provider/media/manual evidence/KG/overlay/replay/index side-effect counters remain zero.\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` remains unchanged.\n\nFocused test command:\n\n```bash\nPYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src pytest -q tests/test_p18_handoff_alignment.py\n```\n\nResult: `6 passed in 11.23s`.\n\n## DeepSeek Advisory\n\nDeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max was run as advisory-only.\n\n- call status: `success`\n- parse status: `pass`\n- verdict: `supports_p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract`\n- recommended next candidate: `P18_closeout_retrospective_then_P19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract`\n- pipeline findings: `0`\n- blockers: `0`\n- high findings: `0`\n- raw model: `deepseek-v4-pro`\n- prompt tokens: `27149`\n- completion tokens: `876`\n- reasoning tokens: `579`\n- reasoning content present: `true`\n\nThe advisory confirmed:\n\n- P18 consumes explicit P17 render/advisory/retrospective paths.\n- P18 aligns to Now-32 manual execution evidence governance without changing active route.\n- Handoff packets remain pending evidence templates.\n- Provider job/media/manual evidence were not performed.\n- KG/overlay/replay and outputs index mutation remain blocked.\n- Old B7 remains reference-only.\n- P19 feedback/repair/replay boundary can be planned only after this P18 closeout retrospective.\n\nDeepSeek remains advisory-only and cannot become accepted operator evidence, accepted overlay, canonical KG, raw KG, replay action, provider evidence, manual evidence, or runtime routing logic.\n\n## Not Landed\n\nP18 intentionally did not land:\n\n- provider job execution;\n- generated media;\n- filled manual/provider evidence;\n- real provider validation;\n- real operator decisions;\n- feedback intake;\n- repair task execution based on real feedback;\n- replay eligibility approval;\n- KG, raw KG, accepted overlay, operator overlay, or replay writes;\n- generated index mutation;\n- old B7 continuation;\n- Now-32 active route change.\n\n## Fragility Or Debt\n\nP18 establishes a deterministic handoff bridge, but it still does not prove provider acceptance, media quality, or operator approval. Every template field that could represent provider/operator evidence remains pending.\n\nThe Now-32 sample outputs referenced by earlier control-plane context were not present in `outputs/quality_gates/...`. P18 did not fabricate replacement samples. It bound to `phase_acceptance.json`, `execution_state.json`, and the code-level Now-32 manual execution log contract in `src/novel2video/platform_neutral_prompt_readiness.py::_manual_execution_log_contract`.\n\nP18 surfaced provider-specific syntax inside handoff/adapter fields by design. P19 and later stages must keep that syntax out of canonical/provider-neutral layers and must not let a handoff template become evidence.\n\n## Stage Recalibration\n\nP18 changes the pipeline state from \"adapter render artifacts exist\" to \"adapter render artifacts are aligned to pending manual handoff governance.\" The next P计划 stage still must not ingest real feedback or run replay. It should freeze the boundary contract for future feedback, repair, and replay so that later real provider/operator evidence has a safe schema and validator path.\n\nThe calibrated next stage is:\n\n`P19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract`\n\nP19 must:\n\n- consume P18 gate, program validation, DeepSeek gate, and this retrospective by explicit path;\n- define real provider result evidence slots and operator observation fields without filling them;\n- define future feedback intake, issue classification, repair task, and replay eligibility schemas;\n- define no-canonical-writeback and no-overlay/replay guards;\n- generate contract/gate/report/control-plane artifacts only unless a later execution stage is explicitly opened;\n- not ingest real feedback, create provider/operator evidence, write KG/overlay/replay, mutate outputs indexes, or continue old B7;\n- run program validation and DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory if P19 produces conclusive readiness/contract artifacts;\n- write a P19 closeout retrospective before P20 deterministic index/archive/workspace final hygiene advances.\n\n## Human Intervention Boundary\n\nNo human intervention is required to record P18 closeout and plan P19 because P19 remains a side-effect-free boundary contract. Human/provider evidence is still required before any actual provider execution, feedback intake, repair from real results, replay, or manual evidence closeout can occur under Now-32 or a later evidence/production plan.\n",
  "p18_contract_excerpt": "# P18 Prompt Readiness Adapter QA Manual Handoff Alignment Contract\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-02T11:10:00+08:00`\n\n本文冻结 P计划 `P18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract` 的规划细则。P18 是 P17 adapter render closeout 后的下一候选阶段。P18 的目标是把 P17 side-effect-free adapter render artifacts 对齐到 Now-32 prompt-readiness/manual execution log governance，但不执行 provider job，不生成 media，不创建 manual/provider evidence，不执行 feedback/replay，不写 KG/overlay/replay，也不改写 `outputs/index.json` / `outputs/index-lite.json`。\n\n## Contract ID\n\n`P18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract`\n\n## Objective\n\nP18 的目标是在 P17 closeout 后建立 compact handoff alignment 层：\n\n- consume P17 render run, P17 program validation/advisory gate, and P17 closeout retrospective by explicit path。\n- consume Now-32 prompt-readiness/manual execution log contract as active evidence boundary。\n- derive prompt/adaptor readiness QA summaries from P17 adapter render rows。\n- derive manual handoff packet templates with pending evidence fields only。\n- align P17 adapter refs with Now-32 manual log schema without creating operator/provider evidence。\n- record unsupported-field and downgrade-note propagation into handoff readiness。\n- keep provider job execution, media generation, manual/provider evidence creation, feedback/replay, KG/overlay/replay, and generated index mutation blocked。\n- keep old B7 downstream outputs as paused reference / diagnostic comparison only。\n- require P18 program validation, DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory, closeout retrospective, and control-plane sync before P19 feedback/repair/replay boundary advances。\n\nP18 output may prepare operator-facing pending evidence packets, but it is not provider execution evidence and not manual operator evidence.\n\n## Required Inputs\n\n- `docs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract_20260602.md`\n- `docs/p17_closeout_retrospective_20260602.md`\n- `docs/p17_adapter_render_contract_20260602.md`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/P17_adapter_render_gate.json`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/P17_adapter_render_validator_report.json`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/P17_adapter_render_input.json`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/P17_adapter_render_rows.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/P17_adapter_render_sequence_index.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/P17_adapter_render_unsupported_fields.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/P17_adapter_render_downgrade_notes.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/P17_adapter_render_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621/manifest.json`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_deepseek_audit_20260602_110641/P17_adapter_render_program_validation.json`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_deepseek_audit_20260602_110641/P17_adapter_render_deepseek_audit_gate.json`\n- `outputs/p17_adapter_render_deepseek_audit_20260602_110641/P17_adapter_render_deepseek_audit_raw.json`\n- `phase_acceptance.json`\n- `execution_state.json`\n\nP18 must not discover P17 through generated indexes. Use explicit paths unless a later deterministic index-refresh stage is opened.\n\n## Execution Boundary\n\nP18 may execute prompt-readiness / adapter-QA / manual-handoff alignment artifacts only:\n\n- allowed: reading P17 artifacts by explicit path, deterministic adapter QA checks, compact handoff template derivation, pending evidence schema mapping, validator/gate/report/html, and manifest。\n- not allowed: provider job execution, media generation, filled manual/provider evidence, fake provider results, fake operator decisions, feedback intake, KG writeback, raw KG writeback, accepted/operator overlay writeback, replay, output deletion, output cold archive, generated index mutation。\n- DeepSeek advisory is required after P18 artifacts, but remains advisory-only and cannot become accepted operator evidence, accepted overlay, KG fact, replay action, provider evidence, manual evidence, or runtime routing logic。\n- Runtime branching by entity name, work title, block title, or sample text is prohibited. Entity names, work titles, block titles, and source excerpts may appear only as evidence/display text.\n\n## Required Outputs\n\nP18 should write a fresh output run dir such as:\n\n`outputs/p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_<timestamp>`\n\nRequired files:\n\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_input.json`\n- `P18_adapter_readiness_qa_rows.jsonl`\n- `P18_manual_handoff_packet_templates.jsonl`\n- `P18_manual_log_schema_alignment.json`\n- `P18_pending_evidence_route_lookup.jsonl`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_validator_report.json`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_gate.json`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment_report.md`\n- `P18_handoff_alignment.html`\n- `manifest.json`\n\n## P18 Validator Matrix\n\n| Validator | Required check | Blocks pass when |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| `p17_authority` | P18 consumes explicit P17 render/advisory/retrospective paths and verifies pass gates | P17 gate/advisory missing, not pass, or P17 retrospective missing |\n| `now32_boundary_alignment` | P18 aligns to Now-32 manual log contract without changing active route | Now-32 boundary missing or `next_entrypoint` changes |\n| `pending_evidence_guard` | Manual handoff packets mark provider/operator fields as pending evidence | Any packet claims real provider/operator evidence |\n| `adapter_traceability` | P18 rows map back to P17 adapter render rows, P15 prompt packets, and P16 boundary rows | orphan handoff row or missing adapter/prompt refs |\n| `unsupported_downgrade_propagation` | P17 unsupported fields and downgrade notes are surfaced in readiness QA | unsupported/downgrade rows are silently dropped |\n| `provider_boundary_guard` | Provider-specific syntax stays inside adapter/handoff fields and never writes canonical/provider-neutral layers | provider syntax appears in canonical/control-plane layers or unbounded fields |\n| `no_provider_execution_guard` | provider job/media/manual evidence counters remain zero | any provider job, media, or manual evidence artifact is generated |\n| `kg_overlay_replay_guard` | KG/overlay/replay counters remain zero | canonical/raw KG, accepted/operator overlay, or replay writeback appears |\n| `old_b7_exclusion` | old B7 remains reference-only | old B7 output is used as active authority |\n| `active_route_guard` | `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.id` remains `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract` | active route changes |\n\n## DeepSeek Advisory Requirements\n\nP18 closeout requires DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory over:\n\n- P18 contract。\n- P17 closeout retrospective。\n- P18 handoff alignment outputs。\n- P18 validator report and gate。\n- Now-32 active route boundary from `execution_state.json` and `phase_acceptance.json`。\n\nExpected pass verdict:\n\n`supports_p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract`\n\nPass requires:\n\n- DeepSeek call status=`success`。\n- parse status",
  "p18_gate_status": {
    "status": "pass",
    "gate_status": "p18_handoff_alignment_pass"
  },
  "p18_validator_summary": {
    "p17_adapter_render_row_count": 5002,
    "adapter_readiness_qa_row_count": 5002,
    "manual_handoff_template_count": 5002,
    "manual_handoff_pending_evidence_count": 5002,
    "route_lookup_row_count": 5002,
    "adapter_render_ref_count": 5002,
    "prompt_packet_ref_count": 5002,
    "p16_boundary_ref_count": 5002,
    "shot_id_trace_count": 5002,
    "shot_number_trace_count": 5002,
    "unsupported_field_refs_propagated_count": 10004,
    "downgrade_note_refs_propagated_count": 5002,
    "provider_specific_syntax_in_handoff_count": 5002,
    "provider_specific_syntax_in_provider_neutral_or_canonical_count": 0,
    "dependency_queue_item_count": 3,
    "future_executable_after_p18_closeout_count": 1,
    "validator_failure_count": 0,
    "active_route_next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
    "p17_deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_p17_adapter_render_contract",
    "old_b7_reference_only": true,
    "old_b7_active_source_ref_count": 0,
    "provider_job_execution_count": 0,
    "media_generation_count": 0,
    "manual_provider_evidence_count": 0,
    "feedback_intake_count": 0,
    "accepted_overlay_write_count": 0,
    "operator_overlay_write_count": 0,
    "canonical_kg_writeback_count": 0,
    "raw_kg_writeback_count": 0,
    "replay_action_count": 0,
    "outputs_index_mutation_count": 0,
    "fake_provider_result_count": 0,
    "fake_operator_decision_count": 0
  },
  "p18_program_validation": {
    "status": "pass",
    "failure_count": 0,
    "summary": {
      "p17_adapter_render_row_count": 5002,
      "adapter_readiness_qa_row_count": 5002,
      "manual_handoff_template_count": 5002,
      "manual_handoff_pending_evidence_count": 5002,
      "route_lookup_row_count": 5002,
      "adapter_render_ref_count": 5002,
      "prompt_packet_ref_count": 5002,
      "p16_boundary_ref_count": 5002,
      "shot_id_trace_count": 5002,
      "shot_number_trace_count": 5002,
      "unsupported_field_refs_propagated_count": 10004,
      "downgrade_note_refs_propagated_count": 5002,
      "provider_specific_syntax_in_handoff_count": 5002,
      "provider_specific_syntax_in_provider_neutral_or_canonical_count": 0,
      "dependency_queue_item_count": 3,
      "future_executable_after_p18_closeout_count": 1,
      "validator_failure_count": 0,
      "active_route_next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
      "p17_deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_p17_adapter_render_contract",
      "old_b7_reference_only": true,
      "old_b7_active_source_ref_count": 0,
      "provider_job_execution_count": 0,
      "media_generation_count": 0,
      "manual_provider_evidence_count": 0,
      "feedback_intake_count": 0,
      "accepted_overlay_write_count": 0,
      "operator_overlay_write_count": 0,
      "canonical_kg_writeback_count": 0,
      "raw_kg_writeback_count": 0,
      "replay_action_count": 0,
      "outputs_index_mutation_count": 0,
      "fake_provider_result_count": 0,
      "fake_operator_decision_count": 0
    }
  },
  "p18_deepseek_gate": {
    "status": "pass",
    "gate_status": "deepseek_advisory_supports_p18_handoff_alignment_contract",
    "summary": {
      "program_validation_status": "pass",
      "program_validation_failure_count": 0,
      "deepseek_call_status": "success",
      "deepseek_parse_status": "pass",
      "deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_p18_prompt_readiness_adapter_qa_manual_handoff_alignment_contract",
      "recommended_next_candidate": "P18_closeout_retrospective_then_P19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract",
      "pipeline_finding_count": 0,
      "pipeline_blocker_count": 0,
      "pipeline_high_count": 0,
      "false_required_confirmation_count": 0,
      "p17_adapter_render_row_count": 5002,
      "adapter_readiness_qa_row_count": 5002,
      "manual_handoff_template_count": 5002,
      "manual_handoff_pending_evidence_count": 5002,
      "route_lookup_row_count": 5002,
      "adapter_render_ref_count": 5002,
      "prompt_packet_ref_count": 5002,
      "p16_boundary_ref_count": 5002,
      "shot_id_trace_count": 5002,
      "shot_number_trace_count": 5002,
      "unsupported_field_refs_propagated_count": 10004,
      "downgrade_note_refs_propagated_count": 5002,
      "provider_specific_syntax_in_handoff_count": 5002,
      "provider_specific_syntax_in_provider_neutral_or_canonical_count": 0,
      "dependency_queue_item_count": 3,
      "future_executable_after_p18_closeout_count": 1,
      "validator_failure_count": 0,
      "active_route_next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
      "p17_deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_p17_adapter_render_contract",
      "old_b7_reference_only": true,
      "old_b7_active_source_ref_count": 0,
      "provider_job_execution_count": 0,
      "media_generation_count": 0,
      "manual_provider_evidence_count": 0,
      "feedback_intake_count": 0,
      "accepted_overlay_write_count": 0,
      "operator_overlay_write_count": 0,
      "canonical_kg_writeback_count": 0,
      "raw_kg_writeback_count": 0,
      "replay_action_count": 0,
      "outputs_index_mutation_count": 0,
      "fake_provider_result_count": 0,
      "fake_operator_decision_count": 0
    }
  },
  "p18_deepseek_raw_meta": {
    "id": "a878c5cd-1427-4e3b-b7f6-1c03d4a31aec",
    "object": "chat.completion",
    "model": "deepseek-v4-pro",
    "usage": {
      "prompt_tokens": 27149,
      "completion_tokens": 876,
      "total_tokens": 28025,
      "prompt_tokens_details": {
        "cached_tokens": 0
      },
      "completion_tokens_details": {
        "reasoning_tokens": 579
      },
      "prompt_cache_hit_tokens": 0,
      "prompt_cache_miss_tokens": 27149
    },
    "finish_reason": "stop",
    "content_chars": 978,
    "reasoning_content_present": true,
    "reasoning_content_chars": 1447
  },
  "p18_surface": {
    "route_lookup_row_count": 5002,
    "manual_schema_alignment_status": "pass",
    "p18_future_executable_candidate_count": 1,
    "p18_next_candidate": "P19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract",
    "p18_input_fingerprint": "9fb2d026533e1a26e576317a40b97237f3dadec386c0cd9ce54644f31dd1dd4b"
  },
  "active_route": {
    "current_stage": "Now-32",
    "current_substage": "Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract",
    "next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
    "phase_acceptance_phase_id": "Now-32",
    "phase_acceptance_substage_id": "Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract"
  },
  "old_b7_policy": {
    "reference_only": true,
    "active_authority": false,
    "old_b7_active_source_ref_count": 0
  },
  "validator_matrix": [
    {
      "validator_id": "p18_authority",
      "purpose": "P19 consumes explicit P18 run/advisory/retrospective paths and verifies pass gates",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "now32_active_route_guard",
      "purpose": "execution_state.next_entrypoint remains Now-32",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "pending_evidence_guard",
      "purpose": "Provider/operator evidence schemas are empty or pending only",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "feedback_intake_guard",
      "purpose": "No real feedback is ingested in P19",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "repair_execution_guard",
      "purpose": "No repaired prompt/adapter/KG/overlay output is generated",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "replay_guard",
      "purpose": "Replay eligibility remains blocked and no replay action exists",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "no_writeback_guard",
      "purpose": "canonical/raw KG and accepted/operator overlay writes are zero",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "provider_media_guard",
      "purpose": "provider job/media counters remain zero",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "outputs_index_guard",
      "purpose": "generated outputs indexes remain untouched",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "old_b7_exclusion",
      "purpose": "old B7 remains paused reference only",
      "blocks_p19_pass": true
    }
  ],
  "policy": {
    "stage": "P19_feedback_repair_replay_boundary_contract",
    "fresh_run_required": true,
    "boundary_contract_only": true,
    "future_schemas_allowed": true,
    "provider_job_execution_allowed": false,
    "media_generation_allowed": false,
    "filled_manual_provider_evidence_allowed": false,
    "feedback_intake_allowed": false,
    "repair_execution_allowed": false,
    "replay_execution_allowed": false,
    "replay_eligibility_approval_allowed": false,
    "accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed": false,
    "operator_overlay_writeback_allowed": false,
    "canonical_kg_writeback_allowed": false,
    "raw_kg_writeback_allowed": false,
    "outputs_index_mutation_allowed": false,
    "old_b7_reference_only": true,
    "execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged": true,
    "advisory_only": true
  },
  "input_fingerprint": "72507ab9585d783e4ca2448f99e2667a555c2372b24d556ca59552e658d5141f"
}