{
  "version": "p17_adapter_render.v1",
  "created_at": "2026-06-02T03:06:25.396175Z",
  "phase": "P17_adapter_render_contract",
  "project_root": "/wwwb/aitools/writer",
  "output_run_dir": "outputs/p17_adapter_render_20260602_110621",
  "operator_authorization_record": {
    "authorized_in_chat": true,
    "authorization_summary": "operator confirmed authorization to enter P17 implementation",
    "provider_execution_still_blocked": true
  },
  "source_artifacts": {
    "p17_contract": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/p17_adapter_render_contract_20260602.md",
      "sha256": "4f119183de0ee4974be9a3b3a7b15007a43e81ebfcd9721cd57c6fac438424b0",
      "size_bytes": 8185,
      "exists": true
    },
    "p17_preentry_project_retrospective": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/p17_preentry_project_retrospective_20260602.md",
      "sha256": "c4e0e7078678d8cc064cb7e61553c3aaf80f9b75966430091ea5ba6bdeb16690",
      "size_bytes": 5155,
      "exists": true
    },
    "p_plan_remaining_closeout_roadmap": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/p_plan_remaining_closeout_roadmap_20260602.md",
      "sha256": "8912fe815ee3ca0bcd46bf87a2c7e652a6b83cf7ffb418fa3b244e42b8a3f4eb",
      "size_bytes": 7239,
      "exists": true
    },
    "p16_closeout_retrospective": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/docs/p16_closeout_retrospective_20260602.md",
      "sha256": "344184baa729bad56390e0dbe86e7913eb03a23084d4ba6169e4431bbb93b545",
      "size_bytes": 7706,
      "exists": true
    },
    "p16_gate": {
      "artifact": "P16_adapter_profile_gate.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_gate.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 9327,
      "sha256": "a8a1362ba93e25ca84ac284968a277a24e87652e7dcac222e2967a98d924d8c7"
    },
    "p16_validator": {
      "artifact": "P16_adapter_profile_validator_report.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_validator_report.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 5452,
      "sha256": "ecd82c069d254101ac633605dc9d5d4656807e2a9c8ee8a07c06d176173b8436"
    },
    "p16_input": {
      "artifact": "P16_adapter_profile_boundary_input.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_input.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 39267,
      "sha256": "9b925b546e157e57add0480650e7332ccef82cd483e2bc4054914c393615803d"
    },
    "p16_boundary_matrix": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_matrix.jsonl",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "039277d65b9e951ce210b1406d7567b311467b33ac3ddca3b1a4d3b246686311",
      "size_bytes": 43839107
    },
    "p16_queue": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_dependency_queue.jsonl",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "98996a8095256a46d69aa03bc09f711f7d65896c9bb1c6843f56b7ea065d9d2d",
      "size_bytes": 3347
    },
    "p16_manifest": {
      "artifact": "manifest.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/manifest.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 5404,
      "sha256": "7ca992cd1f83f1906c4222311e85813c07ca675f1799c271378e8e958f0cf8a2"
    },
    "p16_program_validation": {
      "artifact": "P16_adapter_profile_boundary_program_validation.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_program_validation.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 5252,
      "sha256": "be392cb52a90b8379266449eeddc3ec7cce815d214db76e7c90ba2950d2c7840"
    },
    "p16_deepseek_gate": {
      "artifact": "P16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_gate.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_gate.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 3949,
      "sha256": "c56bed44a91f69b3db0ca8f0c914c13dad9e80fb2f3f96a02846f97e72d30440"
    },
    "p16_deepseek_raw": {
      "artifact": "P16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_raw.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_raw.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 260854,
      "sha256": "ea1ec18e4c190ab0058f4fb9d4f81f3f35b61ad99264a406903296e1e580ad86"
    },
    "p15_prompt_packet_rows": {
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/outputs/p15_prompt_packet_fresh_execution_20260601_155451/P15_prompt_packet_rows.jsonl",
      "exists": true,
      "sha256": "95197ef3ff6d3d3a2a2904c632c511d7d98adac42251f0466e6543b29bfe98ac",
      "size_bytes": 72253998
    },
    "execution_state": {
      "artifact": "execution_state.json",
      "path": "/wwwb/aitools/writer/execution_state.json",
      "exists": true,
      "size_bytes": 66292,
      "sha256": "34ecce002d2876b3c1bc108b200f8a26badc58501dde299d88aade42d32dc9cf"
    }
  },
  "contract_checks": {
    "p17_contract_present": true,
    "p17_contract_adapter_render_scope": true,
    "p17_contract_p16_explicit_authority": true,
    "p17_contract_required_outputs": true,
    "p17_contract_validator_matrix_bound": true,
    "p17_contract_provider_execution_blocked": true,
    "p17_contract_no_kg_overlay_replay": true,
    "p17_contract_old_b7_reference_only": true
  },
  "p17_contract_excerpt": "# P17 Adapter Render Contract\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-02T01:45:00+08:00`\n\n本文冻结 P计划 `P17_adapter_render_contract` 的规划细则。P17 是 P16 adapter/profile boundary planning 之后的下一候选阶段。P17 的目标是把 P15 provider-neutral prompt packet rows 和 P16 boundary matrix 转换为 side-effect-free adapter render artifacts，但不执行 provider job，不生成 media，不创建 manual/provider evidence，不执行 feedback/replay，不写 KG/overlay/replay，也不改写 `outputs/index.json` / `outputs/index-lite.json`。\n\n## Contract ID\n\n`P17_adapter_render_contract`\n\n## Objective\n\nP17 的目标是在 P16 closeout 后建立 adapter render 层：\n\n- consume P16 planning run, P16 program validation/advisory gate, and P16 closeout retrospective by explicit path。\n- consume P15 prompt packet rows as provider-neutral source prompt authority。\n- consume P16 boundary matrix and dependency queue as adapter/profile reentry authority。\n- render side-effect-free adapter payload candidates and reports under a declared adapter profile boundary。\n- record unsupported fields, downgrade notes, omitted fields, validation failures, provider syntax boundaries, and source traceability。\n- keep provider job execution, media generation, manual/provider evidence, feedback/replay, KG/overlay/replay, and generated index mutation blocked。\n- keep old B7 downstream outputs as paused reference / diagnostic comparison only。\n- require P17 program validation, DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory, closeout retrospective, and control-plane sync before any provider/manual execution gate opens。\n\nP17 output may be provider-adapter render data, but it is not provider execution evidence and not manual operator evidence.\n\n## Required Inputs\n\n- `docs/p17_adapter_render_contract_20260602.md`\n- `docs/p16_closeout_retrospective_20260602.md`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_gate.json`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_validator_report.json`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_input.json`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_matrix.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/manifest.json`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_program_validation.json`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_gate.json`\n- `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_raw.json`\n- `outputs/p15_prompt_packet_fresh_execution_20260601_155451/P15_prompt_packet_rows.jsonl`\n- `execution_state.json`\n\nP17 must not discover P16/P15 through generated indexes. Use explicit paths unless a later deterministic index-refresh stage is opened.\n\n## Execution Boundary\n\nP17 may execute adapter render artifact generation only after operator confirmation to enter P17 implementation:\n\n- allowed after confirmation: reading P16/P15 artifacts by explicit path, deterministic adapter render transformation, provider profile boundary checks, unsupported-field reports, downgrade notes, validation reports, gate/report/html, and manifest。\n- not allowed: provider job execution, media generation, manual/provider evidence, fake provider results, fake operator decisions, feedback intake, KG writeback, raw KG writeback, accepted/operator overlay writeback, replay, output deletion, output cold archive, generated index mutation。\n- DeepSeek advisory is required after P17 render artifacts, but remains advisory-only and cannot become accepted operator evidence, accepted overlay, KG fact, replay action, provider evidence, manual evidence, or runtime routing logic。\n- Runtime branching by entity name, work title, block title, or sample text is prohibited. Entity names, work titles, block titles, and source excerpts may appear only as evidence/display text.\n\n## Required Outputs\n\nP17 should write a fresh output run dir such as:\n\n`outputs/p17_adapter_render_<timestamp>`\n\nRequired files:\n\n- `P17_adapter_render_input.json`\n- `P17_adapter_render_rows.jsonl`\n- `P17_adapter_render_sequence_index.jsonl`\n- `P17_adapter_render_unsupported_fields.jsonl`\n- `P17_adapter_render_downgrade_notes.jsonl`\n- `P17_adapter_render_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- `P17_adapter_render_validator_report.json`\n- `P17_adapter_render_gate.json`\n- `P17_adapter_render_report.md`\n- `P17_adapter_render.html`\n- `manifest.json`\n\n## P17 Validator Matrix\n\n| Validator | Required check | Blocks pass when |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| `p16_authority` | P17 consumes explicit P16 planning/advisory/retrospective paths and verifies pass gates | P16 gate/advisory missing, not pass, or P16 retrospective missing |\n| `p15_prompt_packet_authority` | P17 adapter rows map back to P15 prompt packet rows | orphan adapter row or missing prompt packet ref |\n| `adapter_render_schema` | adapter rows expose declared adapter/profile fields and traceable source slots | required adapter fields missing or malformed |\n| `provider_boundary_guard` | provider-specific syntax stays inside adapter render artifacts and never writes canonical/provider-neutral layers | provider syntax appears in canonical/control-plane layers or unbounded fields |\n| `unsupported_field_reporting` | unsupported/omitted/downgraded fields are recorded deterministically | unsupported field is silently dropped |\n| `source_provenance_guard` | P15/P16/P14/P13/P11/P10/P9/source refs remain traceable | source/provenance refs disappear |\n| `no_provider_execution_guard` | provider job/media/manual evidence counters remain zero | any provider job, media, or manual evidence artifact is generated |\n| `kg_overlay_replay_guard` | KG/overlay/replay counters remain zero | canonical/raw KG, accepted/operator overlay, or replay writeback appears |\n| `old_b7_exclusion` | old B7 remains reference-only | old B7 output is used as active authority |\n| `active_route_guard` | `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint.id` remains `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract` | active route changes |\n\n## DeepSeek Advisory Requirements\n\nP17 closeout requires DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory over:\n\n- P17 contract。\n- P16 closeout retrospective。\n- P17 adapter render outputs。\n- P17 validator report and gate。\n- active route boundary from `execution_state.json`。\n\nExpected pass verdict:\n\n`supports_p17_adapter_render_contract`\n\nPass requires:\n\n- DeepSeek call status=`success`。\n- parse status=`pass`。\n- finding/blocker/high=0/0/0。\n- advisory confirms P17 uses P16/P15 fresh artifacts as active authorities。\n- advisory confirms adapter render artifacts are traceable。\n- advisory confirms provider job/media/manual evidence were not performed。\n- advisory confirms KG/overlay/replay/index mutation remain blocked。\n- advisory confirms old B7 remains reference-only。\n\nMissing/skipped/unavailable/unparseable advisory blocks P17 closeout or records `blocked_unavailable`; it never counts as pass.\n\n## Non-Goals\n\n- P17 does not execute provider jobs。\n- P17 does not generate media。\n- P17 does not create manual/provider evidence。\n- P17 does not ingest feedback。\n- P17 does not write KG/overlay/replay。\n- P17 does not repair generated indexes。\n- P17 does not continue old B7 downstream。\n- P17 does not silently perform unlogged LLM enrichment。\n\n## Acceptance Criteria\n\n- Operator confirms P17 implementation may proceed.\n- P17 focused tests pass。\n- P17 adapter render gate pass。\n- P17 program validation pass。\n- DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory pass with verdict=`supports_p17_adapter_render_contract`。\n- P17 closeout retrospective is written before any provider/manual execution gate opens。\n- Control plane is synchronized while `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` remains unchanged。\n\n",
  "p16_closeout_retrospective_excerpt": "# P16 Closeout Retrospective\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-02T01:45:00+08:00`\n\n本文是 P计划 `P16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_contract` 的阶段复盘。P16 在 P15 provider-neutral prompt packet fresh execution closeout 后执行 adapter/profile boundary reentry planning only。P16 没有执行 adapter render、provider-specific payload generation、provider job、media generation、manual/provider evidence、feedback/replay、KG/overlay/replay，也没有改写 `outputs/index.json` / `outputs/index-lite.json`。\n\n## Stage Result\n\n- Status: `pass`\n- P16 planning run: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053`\n- P16 planning gate: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_gate.json`\n- P16 DeepSeek advisory run: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107`\n- P16 DeepSeek gate: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_gate.json`\n- Program validation: `pass`\n- DeepSeek verdict: `supports_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning`\n- finding / blocker / high: `0 / 0 / 0`\n- false required confirmations: `0`\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`: unchanged, still `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\n\n## Actual Landed\n\nP16 landed a fresh adapter/profile boundary planning stage:\n\n- `src/novel2video/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning.py`\n- `scripts/run_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning.py`\n- `scripts/run_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit.py`\n- `tests/test_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning.py`\n\nP16 output artifacts:\n\n- `P16_adapter_profile_boundary_input.json`\n- `P16_adapter_profile_boundary_matrix.jsonl`\n- `P16_adapter_profile_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- `P16_adapter_profile_validator_report.json`\n- `P16_adapter_profile_gate.json`\n- `P16_adapter_profile_report.md`\n- `P16_adapter_profile.html`\n- `manifest.json`\n\nThe boundary matrix creates one row per P15 prompt packet row and exposes future adapter/profile slot candidates for subject, action, camera, timeline, reference slots, style, audio, negative constraints, and task mode. Each row remains planning/control data; it is not an adapter payload row and contains no provider job or media execution evidence.\n\n## Metrics\n\n- P15 prompt packet rows: `5002`\n- P16 adapter/profile boundary rows: `5002`\n- prompt packet refs / shot ids / shot numbers traced: `5002 / 5002 / 5002`\n- P14/P13/P11/P10/P9 refs: `5002 / 5002 / 5002 / 5002 / 5002`\n- adaptation/source scene/chronology refs: `6989 / 6989 / 6989`\n- transition/continuity/merge-drop refs: `5002 / 5002 / 5002`\n- drop refs preserved: `1518 / 1518`\n- adapter/profile slot candidates: `45018`\n- provider-specific syntax in boundary rows: `0`\n- dependency queue items: `5`\n- future executable after P16 closeout: `1`\n- validator failures: `0`\n\nNo-side-effect counters:\n\n- adapter render: `0`\n- provider-specific payload: `0`\n- provider-specific syntax generation: `0`\n- provider job execution: `0`\n- media generation: `0`\n- manual provider evidence: `0`\n- feedback intake: `0`\n- accepted/operator overlay write: `0 / 0`\n- canonical/raw KG writeback: `0 / 0`\n- replay action: `0`\n- outputs index mutation: `0`\n- old B7 active source refs: `0`\n\n## Program Validation\n\nFocused validation passed:\n\n- P16 gate pass.\n- P16 validator pass.\n- Required P16 files exist and are listed in manifest.\n- Boundary rows are complete: `5002`.\n- Dependency queue has one future executable next candidate.\n- P15 program validation remains pass.\n- Provider-specific syntax is absent from P16 boundary rows.\n- Adapter/provider/media/manual-evidence/KG/overlay/replay/index side-effect counters remain zero.\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` remains unchanged.\n\nFocused test command:\n\n```bash\nPYTHONDONTWRITEBYTECODE=1 PYTHONPATH=src pytest -q tests/test_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning.py\n```\n\nResult: `6 passed`.\n\n## DeepSeek Advisory\n\nDeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max was run as advisory-only.\n\n- call status: `success`\n- parse status: `pass`\n- verdict: `supports_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning`\n- pipeline findings: `0`\n- blockers: `0`\n- high findings: `0`\n- raw model: `deepseek-v4-pro`\n- prompt tokens: `68635`\n- completion tokens: `2919`\n- reasoning tokens: `2653`\n- reasoning content present: `true`\n\nThe advisory confirmed:\n\n- P16 contract is artifact-backed.\n- Program validation passed.\n- P15 fresh artifacts are active authorities.\n- Boundary rows are traceable and planning-only.\n- Source provenance is preserved.\n- Adapter render was not performed.\n- Provider/media/manual evidence were not performed.\n- KG/overlay/replay and outputs index mutation remain blocked.\n- Old B7 remains reference-only.\n- `next_entrypoint` remains unchanged.\n- P17 requires a separate contract.\n\nDeepSeek remains advisory-only and cannot become accepted operator evidence, accepted overlay, canonical KG, raw KG, replay action, provider evidence, manual evidence, or runtime routing logic.\n\n## Not Landed\n\nP16 intentionally did not land:\n\n- adapter render payloads;\n- provider-specific payload generation;\n- provider job execution;\n- media generation;\n- manual/provider evidence;\n- feedback intake;\n- KG, raw KG, accepted overlay, operator overlay, or replay writes;\n- generated index mutation;\n- old B7 continuation.\n\n## Fragility Or Debt\n\nP16 confirms that all prompt packet rows can be mapped into future adapter/profile slot families, but it does not prove provider compatibility. Provider compatibility requires a separate adapter render contract with explicit provider profile boundaries, unsupported-field handling, downgrade notes, payload validation, and no execution side effects.\n\nP16 keeps large source/provenance refs available in boundary rows. This is useful for audit but too heavy for direct operator UI or provider handoff. P17 should produce compact adapter render artifacts plus reports, not treat the full P16 matrix as a manual execution packet.\n\nThe project remains intentionally separated from Now-32 manual execution evidence. P17 may render adapter payload candidates if authorized by contract, but it must still not execute provider jobs, generate media, fabricate manual evidence, or ingest feedback.\n\n## Stage Recalibration\n\nP16 changes the pipeline state from \"provider-neutral prompt packets exist\" to \"adapter/profile boundary readiness is planned and validated.\" The next stage should not jump to provider/manual execution.\n\nThe calibrated next stage is:\n\n`P17_adapter_render_contract`\n\nP17 must:\n\n- consume P16 planning artifacts, P16 advisory gate, this retrospective, and P15 prompt packet rows by explicit path;\n- define deterministic adapter render boundaries and provider profile handling before any adapter payload generation;\n- keep provider job execution, media generation, manual/provider evidence, feedback/replay, KG/overlay/replay, and generated index mutation blocked;\n- write adapter render artifacts only if the P17 contract is accepted and the implementation remains side-effect-free;\n- run program validation and DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory before P17 closeout;\n- write a P17 closeout retrospective before any provider/manual execution gate opens.\n\n## Human Intervention Boundary\n\nP16 itself does not require further human intervention.\n\nP17 crosses into provider-adapter render territory. It may be planned now, but actual adapter render execution should proceed only after operator confirmation that P17 may generate side-effect-free adapter payload artifacts. Provider jobs, media generation, and manual/provider evidence remain blocked regardless.\n\n",
  "p17_preentry_retrospective_excerpt": "# P17 Preentry Project Retrospective\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-02T09:13:00+08:00`\n\n本文是在进入 P17 implementation 前，对 P计划当前状态、P16 closeout、P17 contract 和 P计划 final closeout 目标进行的阶段间复盘。它用于校准 `P17_adapter_render_contract` 的落地细则。\n\n## Current Authority\n\n- Formal active route: `Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract`\n- Active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\n- Current `next_entrypoint.id`: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\n- P计划 state: `P16_complete_after_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_closeout_P17_planned`\n- Next P计划 entrypoint: `P17_adapter_render_contract`\n- P17 is not provider execution. P17 may only generate side-effect-free adapter render artifacts after operator confirmation.\n\n## P16 Closeout Evidence\n\nP16 produced adapter/profile boundary rows from explicit P15 prompt packet authority:\n\n- P16 planning run: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053`\n- P16 gate: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_gate.json`\n- P16 boundary matrix: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_boundary_matrix.jsonl`\n- P16 queue: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_20260602_014053/P16_adapter_profile_dependency_queue.jsonl`\n- P16 advisory: `outputs/p16_adapter_profile_boundary_deepseek_audit_20260602_014107`\n- P16 retrospective: `docs/p16_closeout_retrospective_20260602.md`\n\nP16 metrics:\n\n- P15 prompt packet rows: `5002`\n- P16 boundary rows: `5002`\n- prompt packet refs / shot ids / shot numbers traced: `5002 / 5002 / 5002`\n- P14/P13/P11/P10/P9 refs: `5002 / 5002 / 5002 / 5002 / 5002`\n- adaptation/source/chronology refs preserved: `6989 / 6989 / 6989`\n- slot candidates: `45018`\n- provider-specific syntax in boundary rows: `0`\n- validator failures: `0`\n- DeepSeek verdict: `supports_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning`\n- finding/blocker/high: `0 / 0 / 0`\n\n## Project-Level Retrospective\n\nThe rebuilt P计划 mainline now reaches adapter/profile boundary planning. The system has provider-neutral prompt packet rows and an explicit boundary matrix that says which slots can later become adapter/profile fields.\n\nThe major remaining architectural risk is boundary confusion: adapter render artifacts may contain provider-adapter syntax, but they must not become canonical facts, manual evidence, or provider execution claims. P17 must therefore be narrower than a production/provider stage. It should render adapter payload candidates and validator reports only.\n\nThe P计划 closeout target should remain a side-effect-free handoff package ready for Now-32/manual evidence governance. P计划 should not absorb real provider execution, generated media, feedback intake, or replay.\n\n## P17 Calibration\n\nP17 should answer a narrow question: can the P16 boundary matrix and P15 prompt packet rows be deterministically rendered into adapter artifacts while preserving traceability and no-execution boundaries?\n\nP17 must produce:\n\n- one adapter render row per eligible P16/P15 prompt packet row unless blocked by deterministic validation;\n- explicit adapter/profile metadata;\n- unsupported-field and downgrade-note rows;\n- sequence index;\n- dependency queue whose first later candidate is prompt readiness/manual handoff alignment, not provider execution;\n- validator/gate/report/html/manifest.\n\nP17 must not:\n\n- execute provider jobs;\n- generate media;\n- create manual/provider evidence;\n- fabricate provider results;\n- fabricate operator decisions;\n- ingest feedback;\n- write accepted/operator overlay, canonical KG, raw KG, or replay;\n- mutate `outputs/index.json` or `outputs/index-lite.json`;\n- continue old B7.\n\n## P17 Implementation Plan\n\n1. Confirm operator authorization to enter P17 implementation.\n2. Before editing `src/novel2video` or `scripts`, run `python scripts/backup_core_state.py --label p17_adapter_render_contract`.\n3. Add P17 core module for adapter render artifacts.\n4. Add P17 planning/execution script and DeepSeek advisory script.\n5. Add P17 focused tests.\n6. Execute a fresh P17 adapter render run under `outputs/p17_adapter_render_<timestamp>`.\n7. Run program validation and DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory against exact P17 artifacts.\n8. If P17 passes, write P17 closeout retrospective and calibrate P18 prompt readiness / adapter QA / manual handoff alignment.\n9. Sync control plane while keeping `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` unchanged.\n\n## Stop Conditions\n\nStop and request operator intervention if:\n\n- adapter render generation requires real provider credentials or provider job execution;\n- a required field cannot be represented as side-effect-free adapter render data;\n- P17 validation detects provider/media/manual evidence, feedback, KG/overlay/replay, index mutation, or old B7 active authority;\n- DeepSeek advisory is unavailable, unparseable, or returns blocker/high findings;\n- any control-plane update would require changing `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`.\n\n",
  "remaining_roadmap_excerpt": "# P Plan Remaining Closeout Roadmap\n\n更新时间：`2026-06-02T09:13:00+08:00`\n\n本文将 P计划从当前位置到 final closeout 的宏观待办写入控制面。它基于 P16 closeout retrospective、当前 Now-32 active route boundary、P17 adapter render contract，以及项目目标重新校准。\n\n## Current Position\n\n- Formal active route: `Now-32 / Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract`\n- Active route authority: `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint`\n- Current `next_entrypoint.id`: `platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract`\n- P计划 current stage: `P16_complete_after_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_closeout_P17_planned`\n- Current implementation priority: `P计划_P17_adapter_render_contract_after_P16_closeout_retrospective`\n- Latest closeout retrospective: `docs/p16_closeout_retrospective_20260602.md`\n- Next contract: `docs/p17_adapter_render_contract_20260602.md`\n\nP计划 has rebuilt the pipeline from foundation/entity closure through source/context, scene, chronology, adaptation, AI-executable screenplay, shooting_script, shot context, provider-neutral prompt packet rows, and adapter/profile boundary planning. It has not executed provider jobs, generated media, created manual/provider evidence, ingested feedback, written KG/overlay/replay, or mutated generated indexes after P2E.\n\n## Closeout Definition\n\nP计划 should close when the rebuilt pipeline can produce a side-effect-free handoff package that is ready for Now-32/manual evidence governance, while keeping real provider execution and feedback intake outside P计划.\n\nThe final P计划 closeout must prove:\n\n- explicit artifact lineage from source/context through adapter render/handoff;\n- program validation pass for every conclusive stage;\n- DeepSeek v4 pro thinking/max advisory pass for every conclusive stage;\n- old B7 remains paused reference only;\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` remains unchanged unless a separate route update is explicitly authorized;\n- provider job execution, media generation, manual/provider evidence, feedback intake, KG/overlay/replay, and index mutation were not performed by P计划 final stages;\n- next non-P计划 work is governed by Now-32 or a separate evidence/production plan.\n\n## Remaining Macro Stages\n\n### P16.1 Control-Plane Hygiene\n\nPurpose: repair short-entry stale markers before P17 implementation.\n\nRequired actions:\n\n- update `todo.md` and `projectreport.md` top sections from P15/P16 planned to P16 closed/P17 planned;\n- record this roadmap in control plane;\n- keep `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` unchanged;\n- run JSON validation, workflow guard, and `git diff --check`.\n\nExit criteria:\n\n- short-entry files agree with `execution_state.json`, `phase_acceptance.json`, and `workflow_index.json`;\n- no business fresh run, provider/media, KG/overlay/replay, or index mutation occurs.\n\n### P17 Adapter Render Execution\n\nPurpose: generate side-effect-free adapter render artifacts from P16 boundary rows and P15 provider-neutral prompt packet rows.\n\nRequired outputs are defined in `docs/p17_adapter_render_contract_20260602.md`.\n\nAllowed:\n\n- deterministic adapter render transformation;\n- provider profile boundary checks;\n- unsupported-field reports;\n- downgrade notes;\n- validator/gate/report/html/manifest.\n\nBlocked:\n\n- provider job execution;\n- media generation;\n- manual/provider evidence;\n- feedback/replay;\n- KG/overlay/replay writeback;\n- generated index mutation;\n- old B7 continuation.\n\nExit criteria:\n\n- P17 focused tests pass;\n- P17 adapter render gate pass;\n- P17 program validation pass;\n- DeepSeek advisory pass with verdict=`supports_p17_adapter_render_contract`;\n- P17 closeout retrospective written before P18 details advance.\n\n### P18 Prompt Readiness / Adapter QA / Manual Handoff Alignment\n\nPurpose: connect P17 adapter render artifacts to Now-32 manual execution evidence governance without executing providers.\n\nExpected outputs:\n\n- prompt/adaptor readiness QA report;\n- manual handoff packet template with pending evidence fields;\n- manual log schema alignment report;\n- validator/gate/report/html/manifest;\n- P18 closeout retrospective.\n\nBlocked:\n\n- provider execution;\n- media generation;\n- filled manual/provider evidence;\n- feedback intake;\n- replay;\n- KG/overlay writeback.\n\nExit criteria:\n\n- handoff packet is explicitly pending evidence;\n- no fake operator/provider records;\n- Now-32 boundary is preserved;\n- DeepSeek advisory pass.\n\n### P19 Feedback / Repair / Replay Boundary Contract\n\nPurpose: freeze the future evidence-driven feedback/repair/replay boundary without ingesting real feedback.\n\nExpected outputs:\n\n- real feedback intake schema;\n- provider result evidence slot contract;\n- operator observation schema;\n- issue classification schema;\n- repair task schema;\n- replay eligibility rules;\n- no-canonical-writeback guard;\n- validator/gate/report/html/manifest;\n- P19 closeout retrospective.\n\nExit criteria:\n\n- real feedback remains pending;\n- accepted overlay/canonical KG/raw KG/replay remain blocked unless a later human-evidence gate authorizes them;\n- DeepSeek advisory pass.\n\n### P20 Deterministic Index / Archive / Workspace Final Hygiene\n\nPurpose: close the storage and handoff hygiene debt created by many P计划 output runs.\n\nExpected outputs:\n\n- deterministic generated-index refresh contract or explicit no-refresh gate;\n- archive/disposition manifest for P计划 outputs;\n- short-entry compaction update;\n- validator/gate/report/html/manifest;\n- P20 closeout retrospective.\n\nRules:\n\n- do not hand-edit `outputs/index.json` or `outputs/index-lite.json`;\n- if indexes need repair, create a deterministic index refresh stage;\n- do not delete valuable outputs without cold archive manifest/checksum;\n- do not delete protected assets.\n\nExit criteria:\n\n- control-plane entries and short-entry files are compact and current;\n- stale references are either repaired deterministically or explicitly documented;\n- DeepSeek advisory pass if closeout claims depend on governance correctness.\n\n### P21 P计划 Final Closeout\n\nPurpose: formally close Pipeline Rebuild Plan.\n\nExpected outputs:\n\n- `docs/p_plan_final_closeout_retrospective_<date>.md`;\n- final P计划 gate/report;\n- full stage matrix from P0 through P21;\n- artifact refs, program validation status, DeepSeek verdicts, and no-side-effect counters;\n- final handoff statement naming the next governing route/plan.\n\nExit criteria:\n\n- P计划 can prove source-to-handoff traceability;\n- remaining provider/manual/feedback work is outside P计划 and evidence-gated;\n- control plane is synchronized;\n- `execution_state.json.next_entrypoint` remains unchanged unless a separately authorized route update is performed.\n\n## Stop Conditions\n\nStop and request operator intervention if:\n\n- a stage requires provider job execution, media generation, or real manual/provider evidence;\n- DeepSeek advisory is unavailable, unparseable, or returns blocker/high findings for a conclusive stage;\n- validators detect KG/overlay/replay/index mutation outside an explicit authorized stage;\n- a control-plane change would require changing `execution_state.json.next_e",
  "p16_gate_status": {
    "status": "pass",
    "gate_status": "p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning_pass"
  },
  "p16_validator_summary": {
    "p15_prompt_packet_row_count": 5002,
    "adapter_profile_boundary_row_count": 5002,
    "prompt_packet_ref_count": 5002,
    "shot_id_trace_count": 5002,
    "shot_number_trace_count": 5002,
    "p14_readiness_row_ref_count": 5002,
    "p13_shot_context_row_ref_count": 5002,
    "p11_shooting_script_row_ref_count": 5002,
    "p10_readiness_row_ref_count": 5002,
    "p9_screenplay_unit_ref_count": 5002,
    "adaptation_unit_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
    "source_scene_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
    "chronology_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
    "transition_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
    "continuity_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
    "merge_drop_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
    "drop_from_script_scene_refs_preserved": 1518,
    "p15_drop_from_script_scene_count": 1518,
    "slot_candidate_count": 45018,
    "provider_specific_syntax_in_boundary_count": 0,
    "dependency_queue_item_count": 5,
    "future_executable_after_p16_closeout_count": 1,
    "validator_failure_count": 0,
    "active_route_next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
    "p15_deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_p15_prompt_packet_fresh_execution",
    "old_b7_reference_only": true,
    "old_b7_active_source_ref_count": 0,
    "adapter_profile_boundary_planning_count": 1,
    "adapter_render_count": 0,
    "provider_specific_payload_count": 0,
    "provider_specific_syntax_generation_count": 0,
    "provider_job_execution_count": 0,
    "media_generation_count": 0,
    "manual_provider_evidence_count": 0,
    "feedback_intake_count": 0,
    "accepted_overlay_write_count": 0,
    "operator_overlay_write_count": 0,
    "canonical_kg_writeback_count": 0,
    "raw_kg_writeback_count": 0,
    "replay_action_count": 0,
    "outputs_index_mutation_count": 0
  },
  "p16_program_validation": {
    "status": "pass",
    "failure_count": 0,
    "summary": {
      "p15_prompt_packet_row_count": 5002,
      "adapter_profile_boundary_row_count": 5002,
      "prompt_packet_ref_count": 5002,
      "shot_id_trace_count": 5002,
      "shot_number_trace_count": 5002,
      "p14_readiness_row_ref_count": 5002,
      "p13_shot_context_row_ref_count": 5002,
      "p11_shooting_script_row_ref_count": 5002,
      "p10_readiness_row_ref_count": 5002,
      "p9_screenplay_unit_ref_count": 5002,
      "adaptation_unit_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
      "source_scene_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
      "chronology_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
      "transition_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
      "continuity_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
      "merge_drop_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
      "drop_from_script_scene_refs_preserved": 1518,
      "p15_drop_from_script_scene_count": 1518,
      "slot_candidate_count": 45018,
      "provider_specific_syntax_in_boundary_count": 0,
      "dependency_queue_item_count": 5,
      "future_executable_after_p16_closeout_count": 1,
      "validator_failure_count": 0,
      "active_route_next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
      "p15_deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_p15_prompt_packet_fresh_execution",
      "old_b7_reference_only": true,
      "old_b7_active_source_ref_count": 0,
      "adapter_profile_boundary_planning_count": 1,
      "adapter_render_count": 0,
      "provider_specific_payload_count": 0,
      "provider_specific_syntax_generation_count": 0,
      "provider_job_execution_count": 0,
      "media_generation_count": 0,
      "manual_provider_evidence_count": 0,
      "feedback_intake_count": 0,
      "accepted_overlay_write_count": 0,
      "operator_overlay_write_count": 0,
      "canonical_kg_writeback_count": 0,
      "raw_kg_writeback_count": 0,
      "replay_action_count": 0,
      "outputs_index_mutation_count": 0
    }
  },
  "p16_deepseek_gate": {
    "status": "pass",
    "gate_status": "deepseek_advisory_supports_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning",
    "summary": {
      "program_validation_status": "pass",
      "program_validation_failure_count": 0,
      "deepseek_call_status": "success",
      "deepseek_parse_status": "pass",
      "deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_p16_adapter_profile_boundary_reentry_planning",
      "recommended_next_candidate": "P17_adapter_render_contract",
      "pipeline_finding_count": 0,
      "pipeline_blocker_count": 0,
      "pipeline_high_count": 0,
      "false_required_confirmation_count": 0,
      "p15_prompt_packet_row_count": 5002,
      "adapter_profile_boundary_row_count": 5002,
      "prompt_packet_ref_count": 5002,
      "shot_id_trace_count": 5002,
      "shot_number_trace_count": 5002,
      "p14_readiness_row_ref_count": 5002,
      "p13_shot_context_row_ref_count": 5002,
      "p11_shooting_script_row_ref_count": 5002,
      "p10_readiness_row_ref_count": 5002,
      "p9_screenplay_unit_ref_count": 5002,
      "adaptation_unit_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
      "source_scene_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
      "chronology_refs_in_boundary_count": 6989,
      "transition_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
      "continuity_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
      "merge_drop_refs_in_boundary_count": 5002,
      "drop_from_script_scene_refs_preserved": 1518,
      "p15_drop_from_script_scene_count": 1518,
      "slot_candidate_count": 45018,
      "provider_specific_syntax_in_boundary_count": 0,
      "dependency_queue_item_count": 5,
      "future_executable_after_p16_closeout_count": 1,
      "validator_failure_count": 0,
      "active_route_next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract",
      "p15_deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_p15_prompt_packet_fresh_execution",
      "old_b7_reference_only": true,
      "old_b7_active_source_ref_count": 0,
      "adapter_profile_boundary_planning_count": 1,
      "adapter_render_count": 0,
      "provider_specific_payload_count": 0,
      "provider_specific_syntax_generation_count": 0,
      "provider_job_execution_count": 0,
      "media_generation_count": 0,
      "manual_provider_evidence_count": 0,
      "feedback_intake_count": 0,
      "accepted_overlay_write_count": 0,
      "operator_overlay_write_count": 0,
      "canonical_kg_writeback_count": 0,
      "raw_kg_writeback_count": 0,
      "replay_action_count": 0,
      "outputs_index_mutation_count": 0
    }
  },
  "p16_deepseek_raw_meta": {
    "id": "ff43d048-873c-4ec7-916f-76816d30f6e1",
    "object": "chat.completion",
    "model": "deepseek-v4-pro",
    "usage": {
      "prompt_tokens": 68635,
      "completion_tokens": 2919,
      "total_tokens": 71554,
      "prompt_tokens_details": {
        "cached_tokens": 0
      },
      "completion_tokens_details": {
        "reasoning_tokens": 2653
      },
      "prompt_cache_hit_tokens": 0,
      "prompt_cache_miss_tokens": 68635
    },
    "finish_reason": "stop",
    "content_chars": 871,
    "reasoning_content_present": true,
    "reasoning_content_chars": 8287
  },
  "input_surface": {
    "p15_prompt_packet_row_count": 5002,
    "p16_boundary_row_count": 5002,
    "p16_dependency_queue_item_count": 5,
    "future_executable_after_p16_closeout_count": 1,
    "first_future_execution_contract_candidate": "P17_adapter_render_contract"
  },
  "active_route": {
    "current_stage": "Now-32",
    "current_substage": "Prompt-Readiness-Manual-Execution-Log-Contract",
    "next_entrypoint_id": "platform_neutral_prompt_readiness_manual_execution_log_contract"
  },
  "old_b7_policy": {
    "reference_only": true,
    "active_authority": false,
    "old_b7_active_source_ref_count": 0
  },
  "validator_matrix": [
    {
      "validator_id": "p16_authority",
      "purpose": "P17 consumes explicit P16 planning/advisory/retrospective paths and verifies pass gates",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "p15_prompt_packet_authority",
      "purpose": "Adapter render rows map back one-to-one to P15 prompt packet rows",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "adapter_render_schema",
      "purpose": "Adapter rows expose declared adapter/profile fields and traceable source slots",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "provider_boundary_guard",
      "purpose": "Provider syntax stays inside adapter render artifacts only",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "unsupported_field_reporting",
      "purpose": "Unsupported, omitted, and downgraded fields are recorded deterministically",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "source_provenance_guard",
      "purpose": "P15/P16/P14/P13/P11/P10/P9/source refs remain traceable",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "no_provider_execution_guard",
      "purpose": "Provider job/media/manual evidence counters remain zero",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "kg_overlay_replay_guard",
      "purpose": "KG/overlay/replay counters remain zero",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "old_b7_exclusion",
      "purpose": "Old B7 remains reference-only",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    },
    {
      "validator_id": "active_route_guard",
      "purpose": "execution_state.next_entrypoint remains Now-32",
      "blocks_p17_pass": true
    }
  ],
  "policy": {
    "stage": "P17_adapter_render_contract",
    "fresh_run_required": true,
    "adapter_render_allowed_in_p17": true,
    "adapter_render_artifacts_are_evidence": false,
    "adapter_render_artifacts_are_provider_execution": false,
    "provider_specific_syntax_allowed_inside_adapter_render_artifacts": true,
    "provider_specific_syntax_allowed_in_provider_neutral_or_canonical_layers": false,
    "provider_job_execution_allowed": false,
    "media_generation_allowed": false,
    "manual_provider_evidence_allowed": false,
    "feedback_intake_allowed": false,
    "accepted_overlay_writeback_allowed": false,
    "operator_overlay_writeback_allowed": false,
    "canonical_kg_writeback_allowed": false,
    "raw_kg_writeback_allowed": false,
    "replay_execution_allowed": false,
    "outputs_index_mutation_allowed": false,
    "old_b7_reference_only": true,
    "execution_state_next_entrypoint_unchanged": true,
    "advisory_only": true
  },
  "input_fingerprint": "fdb04afc39d852c44ae1004ec189aab70f58079eab99e72a6b1653c9cbc4423a"
}