passp1_audit_complete_ready_for_B4_4ADeepSeek: success / pass
| ID | Severity | Finding | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| P1F0001 | blocker | B4.4 direct data lineage lacks a B4.4-level DeepSeek v4 pro thinking audit artifact. | Implement B4.4A parallel audit/rebase before reusing B4.4/B4.5 as conclusive review or overlay surfaces. |
| P1F0002 | high | B4 builder chain is deterministic and has no API call site for mandatory P计划 parallel DeepSeek review. | Keep deterministic builders, but add a separate P计划 audit stage that runs DeepSeek v4 pro thinking and blocks conclusive outputs when missing. |
| P1F0003 | high | B4.5 active preview depends on the unaudited B4.4 contract source. | Treat current B4.5 as reusable harness only; rerun as B4.5R after audited B4.4R regeneration. |
{
"advisory_findings": [
{
"agreement": "agree",
"finding_id": "P1F0001",
"reason": "The artifact lineage shows B4.4 lacks a DeepSeek v4 pro thinking audit artifact. The artifact metadata confirms 'b4_4_contains_deepseek_v4_pro_thinking': false, and the policy mandates deepseek_parallel_review.",
"recommended_action": "Implement a B4.4A parallel audit stage that uses DeepSeek v4 pro thinking to review the B4.4 template, blocking downstream use until it passes.",
"severity": "blocker"
},
{
"agreement": "agree",
"finding_id": "P1F0002",
"reason": "Code signals for all B4 builder modules show no call_chat or call_deepseek_lane calls, confirming the deterministic nature. Without a dedicated audit API call, the mandatory P计划 parallel review is absent.",
"recommended_action": "Add a separate audit stage that invokes DeepSeek v4 pro thinking on the builder outputs and acts as a gate.",
"severity": "high"
},
{
"agreement": "agree",
"finding_id": "P1F0003",
"reason": "B4.5 overlay intake directly depends on B4.4 artifact; if B4.4 is unaudited, B4.5 inherits that risk. The evidence shows the chain from B4.4 to B4.5 without an intermediate audit.",
"recommended_action": "Regenerate B4.5 as B4.5R only after B4.4 has been audited and rebased.",
"severity": "high"
}
],
"missed_risks": [
{
"description": "B4.3's HUMAN_MODEL_LABEL_RE may accidentally block or misclassify a legitimate DeepSeek advisory audit signature if not updated. Integrating an audit step without adjusting this filter could cause false rejections.",
"risk_id": "MISSED_RISK_001",
"severity": "medium"
},
{
"description": "The program audit focuses on B4.4, but the entire B4 chain (B4.1 through B4.3) also lacks deep thinking validation. A future B4.4A might need to audit the full input lineage to ensure correctness.",
"risk_id": "MISSED_RISK_002",
"severity": "high"
}
],
"overall_verdict": "supports_program_audit",
"parse_status": "pass",
"recommended_next_stage": "B4.4A_alias_surface_template_parallel_audit_and_rebase_before_overlay_intake",
"reviewed_finding_ids": [
"P1F0001",
"P1F0002",
"P1F0003"
]
}{
"accepted_overlay_writeback": false,
"b4_4a_allowed": true,
"b4_5_allowed": false,
"b5_replay_allowed": false,
"canonical_writeback": false,
"created_at": "2026-05-25T08:13:21.340985Z",
"failures": [],
"gate_status": "p1_audit_complete_ready_for_B4_4A",
"next_required_action": "B4.4A_alias_surface_template_parallel_audit_and_rebase_before_overlay_intake",
"raw_kg_writeback": false,
"replay_action_count": 0,
"status": "pass",
"summary": {
"accepted_overlay_writeback_count": 0,
"b4_4_contains_deepseek_v4_pro_thinking": false,
"b4_artifact_count": 7,
"b4_builder_api_call_signal_count": 0,
"b4_direct_chain_contains_deepseek_v4_pro_thinking": false,
"blocker_count": 1,
"canonical_writeback_count": 0,
"code_file_count": 20,
"deepseek_call_status": "success",
"deepseek_missed_program_finding_count": 0,
"deepseek_missed_risk_count": 2,
"deepseek_overall_verdict": "supports_program_audit",
"deepseek_parse_status": "pass",
"deepseek_reviewed_program_finding_count": 3,
"finding_count": 3,
"high_count": 2,
"raw_kg_writeback_count": 0,
"replay_action_count": 0
},
"version": "p1_code_level_pipeline_audit_gate.v1"
}