{ "version": "entity_identity_replay_guard.v1", "created_at": "2026-05-22T04:57:48.238155Z", "status": "pass", "work_id": "work_scope_unset", "source_artifacts": { "decision_overlay": "02n_entity_identity_accepted_decision_overlay.json", "human_decision_validation_report": "02n_entity_identity_human_decision_validation_report.json", "kg_store_adjudicated": "02k_kg_store_adjudicated.json", "kg_store_decision_replay": "02m_kg_store_decision_replay.json", "entity_registry_decision_replay": "02m_entity_registry_decision_replay.json", "replay_report": "02m_entity_identity_decision_replay_report.json", "operator_corrections": "02n_entity_identity_operator_corrections.json" }, "policy": { "work_scoped_only": true, "canonical_writeback": false, "validates_replay_only": true, "does_not_sync_work_entity_pool": true }, "summary": { "accepted_decision_count": 15, "replayed_accepted_decision_count": 15, "accepted_decision_replay_coverage": 1.0, "replay_guard_blocker_count": 0, "violation_count": 0, "stale_type_leak_count": 0, "work_policy_scope_violation_count": 0, "relation_endpoint_orphan_count": 0, "evidence_exact_coverage": 1.0, "canonical_mutation_count": 0, "unresolved_identity_blocker_count": 22, "work_policy_patch_candidate_count": 3 }, "constraints": [ { "decision_id": "EID000001", "review_item_id": "EIR000001", "canonical_name": "五行遁法", "decision_type": "merge_entities", "target_entity_id": "E000253", "required_type": "", "source_type": "功法体系", "source_entity_types": [ "术法神通", "功法体系" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "功法体系", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Both entities refer to the 五行遁法 concept. E000048 captures its specific techniques and attributes, while E000253 describes it as a widely-spread cultivation system. They are essentially the same entity seen from different perspectives. Merging with type '功法体系' better reflects the overarching system, under which specific techniques exist.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-22T12:56:59+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000002", "review_item_id": "EIR000002", "canonical_name": "基础剑气入门", "decision_type": "merge_entities", "target_entity_id": "E000066", "required_type": "", "source_type": "物品", "source_entity_types": [ "功法体系", "物品" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "物品", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "E000051 is described as a technique/system but the evidence clearly refers to the book '基础剑气入门' (黄色旧竹简, 入门剑法). E000066 is the same physical item (取出《基础剑气入门》在膝上展开细看). They are the same object. Merge into type '物品' as the physical book.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-22T12:56:59+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000003", "review_item_id": "EIR000003", "canonical_name": "幽泉", "decision_type": "retype_entity", "target_entity_id": "E000045", "required_type": "职位称号", "source_type": "功法体系", "source_entity_types": [ "功法体系" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "组织", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "功法体系", "组织" ], "operator_correction_id": "EICOR000001", "operator_correction": "幽泉是道祖的尊号，不是组织。", "decision_reason": "Operator correction: 幽泉是道祖的尊号，不是组织。\nPrevious lead/advisory reason retained for audit only: Evidence clearly shows 幽泉 acting as an agent (被幽泉灭门了, 幽泉灭门北辰剑宗) and descriptions indicate it is a 道统/势力. The current type '功法体系' is incorrect. Retype to '组织'.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-17T04:12:30+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000004", "review_item_id": "EIR000004", "canonical_name": "归尘真炁", "decision_type": "merge_entities", "target_entity_id": "E000096", "required_type": "", "source_type": "功法体系", "source_entity_types": [ "概念法则", "功法体系" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "功法体系", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Both entities refer to the same 归尘真炁. E000096 treats it as a technique to cultivate, E000197 as a substance that can be contaminated. They are likely the same energy/technique. Merge into type '功法体系' since it is practiced by characters.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-22T12:56:59+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000005", "review_item_id": "EIR000005", "canonical_name": "渊识", "decision_type": "merge_entities", "target_entity_id": "E000222", "required_type": "", "source_type": "物品", "source_entity_types": [ "物品", "功法体系" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "物品", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "E000222 is the physical painting (画卷) containing the insights of 渊识, E000264 is the technique/aspect obtained through comprehending it. They are the same object. Merge into type '物品' as the artwork.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-22T12:56:59+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000006", "review_item_id": "EIR000006", "canonical_name": "煞尸", "decision_type": "merge_entities", "target_entity_id": "E000250", "required_type": "", "source_type": "生物种族", "source_entity_types": [ "概念法则", "生物种族" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "生物种族", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "E000172 contains detailed descriptions of 煞尸 as a creature type, E000250 treats it as a biological race. They refer to the same undead monster category. Merge into type '生物种族'.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-22T12:56:59+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000007", "review_item_id": "EIR000007", "canonical_name": "玄天剑意", "decision_type": "merge_entities", "target_entity_id": "E000050", "required_type": "人物", "source_type": "概念法则", "source_entity_types": [ "概念法则", "物品", "术法神通", "系统面板" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "概念法则", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "概念法则", "物品", "术法神通", "系统面板" ], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Operator correction: 玄天剑意在本作品中绝大部分作为可行动、可意念对话、可附着主角神魂的 NPC-like 魂魄/剑意存在。同名 物品/术法神通/系统面板 节点是抽取分型残留，应合并到 E000050 并重分类为人物/sword_consciousness。", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-17T04:12:30+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000008", "review_item_id": "EIR000008", "canonical_name": "童子", "decision_type": "merge_entities", "target_entity_id": "E000015", "required_type": "", "source_type": "人物", "source_entity_types": [ "职位称号", "人物" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "人物", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "E000034 describes the servant roles (童子 as a title), while E000015 refers to the same group of boys disappearing. They are the same character group. Merge into type '人物' representing the collective.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "Roy", "accepted_at": "2026-05-19T09:27:53+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000009", "review_item_id": "EIR000009", "canonical_name": "观主", "decision_type": "merge_entities", "target_entity_id": "E000278", "required_type": "", "source_type": "人物", "source_entity_types": [ "人物", "职位称号" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "人物", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "E000278 represents a specific person (观主 doing actions), while E000117 represents the title/position. They likely refer to the same individual. Merge into type '人物' with the title as attribute.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "Roy", "accepted_at": "2026-05-19T09:27:53+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000013", "review_item_id": "EIR000013", "canonical_name": "墓门", "decision_type": "rename_or_reanchor_entity", "target_entity_id": "E000190", "required_type": "物品", "source_type": "组织", "source_entity_types": [ "组织" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "人物", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "组织", "人物" ], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Operator correction: EIBR000016 的前后文是“手掌爪拍铁门的震响”，不是组织；当前“墓门”是 span/reanchor 错位，应重锚到“铁门”。", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-17T04:12:30+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000015", "review_item_id": "EIR000015", "canonical_name": "干尸", "decision_type": "retype_entity", "target_entity_id": "E000193", "required_type": "生物种族", "source_type": "其他", "source_entity_types": [ "其他" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "人物", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "其他", "人物" ], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Operator accepted EIR000012 retype after 02s allowed-decision expansion: 干尸 is treated as an undead creature/species class in this xianxia/liaozhai/shenmo context.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "Roy", "accepted_at": "2026-05-19T10:40:27+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000022", "review_item_id": "EIR000022", "canonical_name": "斗剑", "decision_type": "mark_non_entity", "target_entity_id": "E000322", "required_type": "事件", "source_type": "物品", "source_entity_types": [ "物品" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "物品" ], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Operator correction: 斗剑在本作品里是一种行为，意思接近单挑/比剑，不应作为稳定实体进入 canonical entity registry。", "canonical_entity_allowed": false, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-17T04:12:30+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000027", "review_item_id": "EIR000027", "canonical_name": "江湖人", "decision_type": "rename_or_reanchor_entity", "target_entity_id": "E000174", "required_type": "", "source_type": "人物", "source_entity_types": [ "人物" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Operator accepted reanchor: evidence span says “几个高手”, and the surrounding context describes combat with minor opponents/extras rather than a named 江湖人 entity.\nPrevious lead/advisory reason retained for audit only: Weak evidence entity (江湖人) with only one conflict relation. Needs human review.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-18T10:21:28+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000030", "review_item_id": "EIR000030", "canonical_name": "画卷", "decision_type": "rename_or_reanchor_entity", "target_entity_id": "E000032", "required_type": "", "source_type": "物品", "source_entity_types": [ "物品" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "", "forbidden_entity_types": [], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Operator accepted reanchor: exact evidence says “山主抱着一卷画轴”; the extracted canonical name 画卷 should be reanchored to the literal object name 画轴.\nPrevious lead/advisory reason retained for audit only: Weak evidence entity (画卷) with only one relation. Needs human review.", "canonical_entity_allowed": true, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-18T10:21:28+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" }, { "decision_id": "EID000033", "review_item_id": "EIR000033", "canonical_name": "贼子", "decision_type": "mark_non_entity", "target_entity_id": "E000257", "required_type": "称谓", "source_type": "其他", "source_entity_types": [ "其他" ], "deepseek_advisory_target_type": "", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "其他" ], "operator_correction_id": "", "operator_correction": "", "decision_reason": "Operator correction: 贼子是对一类人的蔑称/泛称，类似“小偷/王八蛋”，不是稳定实体。", "canonical_entity_allowed": false, "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-17T04:12:30+08:00", "work_id": "work_scope_unset" } ], "work_policy_patch_candidates": [ { "work_id": "work_scope_unset", "canonical_name": "幽泉", "entity_type": "职位称号", "identity_notes": "幽泉是道祖的尊号，不是组织。", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "功法体系", "组织" ], "source_decision_id": "EID000003", "source_review_item_id": "EIR000003", "target_entity_id": "E000045", "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-17T04:12:30+08:00", "review_status": "approved" }, { "work_id": "work_scope_unset", "canonical_name": "玄天剑意", "entity_type": "人物", "identity_notes": "Operator correction: 玄天剑意在本作品中绝大部分作为可行动、可意念对话、可附着主角神魂的 NPC-like 魂魄/剑意存在。同名 物品/术法神通/系统面板 节点是抽取分型残留，应合并到 E000050 并重分类为人物/sword_consciousness。", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "概念法则", "物品", "术法神通", "系统面板" ], "source_decision_id": "EID000007", "source_review_item_id": "EIR000007", "target_entity_id": "E000050", "accepted_by": "operator_chat_user", "accepted_at": "2026-05-17T04:12:30+08:00", "review_status": "approved" }, { "work_id": "work_scope_unset", "canonical_name": "干尸", "entity_type": "生物种族", "identity_notes": "Operator accepted EIR000012 retype after 02s allowed-decision expansion: 干尸 is treated as an undead creature/species class in this xianxia/liaozhai/shenmo context.", "forbidden_entity_types": [ "其他", "人物" ], "source_decision_id": "EID000015", "source_review_item_id": "EIR000015", "target_entity_id": "E000193", "accepted_by": "Roy", "accepted_at": "2026-05-19T10:40:27+08:00", "review_status": "approved" } ], "violations": [], "gate": { "version": "entity_identity_replay_guard_gate.v1", "created_at": "2026-05-22T04:57:48.238155Z", "status": "blocked", "downstream_scene_screenplay_allowed": false, "guard_replay_correctness_pass": true, "summary": { "accepted_decision_count": 15, "replayed_accepted_decision_count": 15, "accepted_decision_replay_coverage": 1.0, "replay_guard_blocker_count": 0, "violation_count": 0, "stale_type_leak_count": 0, "work_policy_scope_violation_count": 0, "relation_endpoint_orphan_count": 0, "evidence_exact_coverage": 1.0, "canonical_mutation_count": 0, "unresolved_identity_blocker_count": 22, "work_policy_patch_candidate_count": 3 }, "blocking_reasons": [ "unresolved_identity_review_items" ] } }